MARWAN docs NOC knowledge base
DocsMail

Choosing a FOSS mail and collaboration suite in 2026

mailcow, Mail-in-a-Box, Modoboa, Grommunio, poste.io, Forward Email, Carbonio CE, Zimbra and Stalwart compared, from MARWAN's own search for a replacement mail platform, and why we chose Stalwart.

Published Sami Ait Ali Oulahcen

Why we went looking#

For years MARWAN ran its mail on Zimbra. When the time came to reinstall the platform, we expected to pick a modern open-source replacement in an afternoon. It took much longer. Every suite we tried did part of the job well and fell short somewhere else, and for a while we were ready to go back to Zimbra. At the last moment we found Stalwart, and that is what we run today, with Bulwark as the webmail.

This page is the comparison we wish we'd had: what each project is, what it's built on, and where it fitted or didn't fit a national research network that hosts mail for its own staff and member institutions.

What we needed#

  • Standard mail done right: SMTP with SPF, DKIM, DMARC and ARC, IMAP, spam filtering, quotas.
  • Several domains and thousands of mailboxes, with delegated administration.
  • Calendars and contacts that work on phones and desktop clients.
  • A webmail users accept.
  • Free software we can run on our own Proxmox infrastructure, with no feature locked behind a licence we would need later.
  • A healthy project: regular releases, security fixes, and a community we can work with.

The landscape at a glance#

Suite What it is Licence Built on Webmail Calendar & contacts Exchange / ActiveSync
mailcow Dockerised mail server suite GPL-3.0 Postfix, Dovecot, Rspamd, SOGo SOGo SOGo (CalDAV/CardDAV) ActiveSync via SOGo
Mail-in-a-Box One-box appliance for a few domains CC0 Postfix, Dovecot, Roundcube, Nextcloud Roundcube Nextcloud (CalDAV/CardDAV) Basic, via Z-Push
Modoboa Django admin and webmail on top of a classic stack ISC Postfix, Dovecot, Radicale Modoboa webmail Radicale No
Grommunio Exchange-compatible groupware AGPL-3.0; free version limited to 5 users Gromox, Postfix grommunio Web Yes Yes: MAPI/HTTP, EWS, ActiveSync
poste.io Single Docker image mail server Proprietary (free tier) Haraka, Dovecot, Rspamd Roundcube No No
Forward Email Hosted privacy-focused mail service, self-hostable MPL-2.0 / BUSL-1.1 Node.js, SQLite per mailbox Through clients CalDAV/CardDAV No
Carbonio CE Zimbra-derived suite by Zextras Open source (CE) Zimbra code base, Postfix Carbonio web client Yes Paid editions only
Zimbra The classic all-in-one suite Source available; no official free builds since 9.0 Jetty, Postfix, OpenLDAP, MariaDB Zimbra web client Yes Network Edition only
Stalwart All-in-one mail and collaboration server in Rust AGPL-3.0 (enterprise licence optional) Its own SMTP, IMAP, JMAP, POP3, CalDAV, CardDAV, WebDAV Any IMAP or JMAP webmail (we use Bulwark) Built in No (standard protocols)

Notes on each#

mailcow#

The most popular self-hosted suite, and for good reason: a complete, well-integrated stack in Docker Compose with a good admin interface and SOGo for groupware. Its weak points for us were the large container footprint to maintain, and the project's community, which we found unwelcoming when we asked questions.

Mail-in-a-Box#

Excellent at what it promises: one Ubuntu box, a handful of domains, sensible defaults, and it manages DNS for you. That opinionated design is also its limit. It isn't built for thousands of mailboxes across many institutions, or for being integrated into an existing infrastructure.

Modoboa#

A clean admin interface on top of the familiar Postfix and Dovecot, with a permissive licence. The groupware side (Radicale for calendars and contacts) is thin compared with the others.

Grommunio#

The most complete open-source answer if you need Outlook to work natively, with MAPI over HTTP, EWS and ActiveSync. But the free community version is limited to 5 users, which doesn't work for a network that hosts mail for thousands of people. That was the main reason we left it out.

poste.io#

Very easy to start: one container and a web wizard. But the free edition isn't open source, and features we would need are in the paid tier, which rules it out for us.

Forward Email#

Interesting design (per-mailbox encrypted SQLite) and largely open source, but it is first a hosted service. Self-hosting it is possible, but that isn't where the project puts its effort.

Carbonio CE#

The closest to Zimbra, which made it attractive for our users. What ruled it out was how slowly bugs get fixed: some have been open for more than two years, still unfixed even though many users have reported and complained about them.

Zimbra#

What we knew. It still works, but there have been no official open-source builds since Zimbra 9, and the platform (Java, OpenLDAP, MariaDB, many moving parts) is heavy to maintain for what we use. Going back to it would have meant choosing the familiar over the future.

Stalwart#

A single Rust binary that implements the mail protocols itself: SMTP, IMAP, POP3, JMAP, CalDAV, CardDAV and WebDAV, with spam filtering, DKIM/ARC signing, DMARC reports and TLS certificates built in. It stores data in RocksDB, PostgreSQL, MySQL or S3-compatible storage, and can authenticate against LDAP or OpenID Connect. Configuration and administration happen in a web interface. For us it meant far fewer components to keep up to date, modern protocols, and a project that answers.

Stalwart has no webmail of its own. We pair it with Bulwark, which speaks JMAP to Stalwart.

What we chose and why#

We run Stalwart with Bulwark as webmail, on Proxmox VE. In short:

  • One component instead of six. Postfix, Dovecot, Rspamd, OpenDKIM, a CalDAV server and an ACME client are all replaced by one service.
  • Modern protocols. JMAP for webmail and future clients, plus IMAP, CalDAV and CardDAV for everything else.
  • Free software without a crippled edition for the features we use.
  • An active, responsive project.

The trade-offs we accepted: no Exchange protocols (Outlook works over IMAP, with CalDAV and CardDAV through add-ins), and a younger project than Zimbra.

Further reading#